John Herman Our creepiness rating 💀💀💀💀💀
Mackinaw City tourism tells the legend that keeper John Herman, back from a night of drinking on October 14, 1900, locked his assistant in the tower, then vanished, presumed drowned, and haunted the light for ten years. Sources differ: the same page says research shows Herman actually died of a heart attack on Mackinac Island that day, under a doctor's care. Source: Mackinaw City Tourism.
Facts below are drawn from the linked sources.
Real history
The light operated from 1851 until 1912; during World War II the Navy used it for bombing practice (Wikipedia). In 2021 the preservation society abandoned efforts to save it (Harbor Light News, 2021).
Ghost stories
These are reported legends, not verified events. The creepiness score (1–5) is Spook Atlas's own editorial rating, not a measurement.
Then and now
Public access
Closed to the public The light stands offshore on a crumbling crib with no public access (Harbor Light News, 2021). Last checked: Nov 1, 2026.
Explore more
- More places in Mackinaw City and Michigan
- More haunted & abandoned lighthouses
- More haunted & abandoned ruins
- Nearby: Fort Mackinac (Mackinac Island, MI), Mission Point Resort (Mackinac Island, MI), Seul Choix Point Light (Gulliver, MI), Point Iroquois Light (Brimley, MI)
⚠️ Please read: This information may be outdated and conditions change. Verify access with the owner or operator before you go. Spook Atlas does not encourage trespassing. Entering private, closed or condemned property can be illegal and dangerous. Report a correction.
Reader experiences
Not yet accepting submissions. Reader stories are coming later; this form is switched off and sends nothing. All stories are moderated before they appear. Posts describing trespassing, break-ins or how to get into closed areas are removed.
No reader experiences yet. Be the first to share yours.